Reimagining Federalism: Constitutional Challenges in Pakistan’s Multi-Tier Governance System
Keywords:
Constitutional accountability, Proportionality doctrine, Separation of powers, Fundamental rights protection, public interest litigation, Rule of law, Arbitrary state action, Judicial activism, Constitutional moralityAbstract
Federalism in Pakistan is both a constitutional framework and a contested political practice, shaped by historical centralization, amendments, and political bargaining. This study examines the constitutional and institutional challenges facing Pakistan’s multi-tier governance, including ambiguities in legislative powers, fiscal imbalances from National Finance Commission arrangements, weak intergovernmental bodies like the Council of Common Interests, and the uneven integration of the former Federally Administered Tribal Areas into Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. Using a qualitative approach, the research analyses constitutional texts, policy documents, judicial rulings, and scholarly literature to identify gaps between legal provisions and practical implementation. Findings indicate that constitutional amendments alone cannot ensure effective federalism; sustainable governance requires fiscal equity, strong intergovernmental mechanisms, and a normative shift toward cooperative governance. The article concludes with legal, institutional, and policy recommendations to strengthen cooperative federalism, promote inclusive development, and enhance stability, emphasizing that Pakistan’s federal structure must combine constitutional design with functional and equitable institutional practices.
References
Agrawal, D. R., Brueckner, J. K., & Brülhart, M. (2024). Fiscal federalism in the twenty-first century. Annual Review of Economics, 16.
Ahmed, F. A., Akhtar, A., & Gul, S. (2025). The role of urban design in preventing crime: insights into environmental criminology. PAKISTAN ISLAMICUS (An International Journal of Islamic & Social Sciences), 5(01), 01-13.
Ahmed, F. A., Gul, S., & Shahzad, S. (2025). Ensuring Accountability And Transparency In Ai-Driven Corporate Governance.
Ahmed, F. A., Zafar, S., & Gul, S. (2025). Analyzing PECA amendments: Press freedom, democratic values, and digital regulation in Pakistan. Traditional Journal of Law and Social Sciences, 4(01), 41-51.
Ali, W., Mahmood, S., Alam, A., & Khan, A. (2025). Rebuilding Democracy: An In-Depth Analysis of Pakistan's Political Transformation (2008-2015). Social Science Review Archives, 3(1), 1252-1263.
Amjad, S., USMAN, M., & KHAN, A. Environmental Jurisprudence in Pakistan: A Comprehensive Analysis of National Laws, Judicial Role, and Legislative Instruments Impacting Air Quality and Public Health.
Anantharaman, S. (2025). Reimagining Federal Unity in a Geopolitical Hotspot: India’s Constitutional Integration of Jammu and Kashmir in International Perspective.
Arnold, M. N. G., Balakrishnan, M. R., Barkbu, M. B. B., Davoodi, M. H. R., Lagerborg, A., Lam, M. W. R., ... & Zettelmeyer, M. J. (2022). Reforming the EU fiscal framework: strengthening the fiscal rules and institutions. International Monetary Fund.
Bhatti, S. M., & Alqama, K. (2025). Democratic Consolidation In Pakistan: A Critical Analysis Of The Role Of Institutions, Elites, And Civil Society (2008-2023). International Journal of Social Sciences Bulletin, 3(10), 825-848.
Darshini, J. S., & Gayithri, K. (2024). Indian Fiscal Federalism and Resource Gap of State Governments: Measurement and Analysis. Review of Development and Change, 29(1), 44-66.
Dougan, M. (2024). EU Competences In An Age of Complexity And Crisis: Challenges And Tensions In the System of Attributed Powers. Common Market Law Review, 61(1).
Fallon Jr, R. H. (2022). Constitutional Remedies: In One Era and Out the Other. Harv. L. Rev., 136, 1300.
Gul, S., Ahmad, R., & Rahman, S. U. (2025). The Myth of Neutrality: Judicial Review, Ideology, and Constitutional Interpretation in Pakistan and the United Kingdom. The Critical Review of Social Sciences Studies, 3(2), 1742-1754.
Gul, S., Malik, W., & Qureshi, G. M. (2025). Cybersecurity And Sovereignty: The Role Of International Law In Governing State Behaviour In Cyberspace. Policy Journal of Social Science Review, 3(5), 121-135.
Holbrook, L. (2024). Ambiguity in National Security Powers under the UK's National Security and Investment Act 2021: Implications for Executive Accountability and Judicial Review. Cambridge L. Rev., 9, 52.
Husnain, G. (2021). Governance of cross border regions and SEZs: the case of gwadar under China-Pakistan economic corridor (CPEC).
Hussain, N., Khan, A., & Chandio, L. A. (2023). Legal Safeguards against Mob Justice: An Analysis of Blasphemy Laws in Pakistan and International Human Rights Norms.
Hussain, N., Khan, A., Chandio, L. A., & Oad, S. (2023). Individual criminal responsibility for the crime of aggression: the role of the ICC's Leadership Clause. Pakistan journal of humanities and social sciences, 11(1), 223-232.
Kahn, A., & Wu, X. (2020). Impact of digital economy on intellectual property law. J. Pol. & L., 13, 117.
Khan, A. (2022). E-commerce Regulations in Emerging Era: The Role of WTO for Resolving the Complexities of Electronic Trade. ASR Chiang Mai University Journal Of Social Sciences And Humanities.
Khan, A. (2024). The Emergence of the Fourth Industrial Revolution and its Impact on International Trade. ASR: CMU Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities (2024) Vol, 11.
Khan, A. (2024). The intersection of artificial intelligence and international trade laws: Challenges and opportunities. IIUMLJ, 32, 103.
Khan, A. S. I. F., Amjad, S. O. H. A. I. L., & Usman, M. U. H. A. M. M. A. D. (2020). The Evolution of Human Rights Law in the Age of Globalization. Pakistan journal of law, analysis and wisdom.
Khan, A., & Jiliani, M. A. H. S. (2023). Expanding The Boundaries Of Jurisprudence In The Era Of Technological Advancements. IIUMLJ, 31, 393.
Khan, A., & Usman, M. (2023). The effectiveness of international law: a comparative analysis. International Journal of Contemporary Issues in Social Sciences, 2(3), 780-786.
Khan, A., & Ximei, W. (2022). Digital economy and environmental sustainability: do information communication and technology (ICT) and economic complexity matter?. International journal of environmental research and public health, 19(19), 12301.
Khan, A., Amjad, S., & Usman, M. (2020). The Role of Customary International Law in Contemporary International Relations. International Review of Social Sciences, 8(08), 259-265.
Khan, A., Bhatti, S. H., & Shah, A. (2021). An overview on individual criminal liability for crime of aggression. Liberal Arts and Social Sciences International Journal (LASSIJ), 5(1), 432-442.
Khan, A., Hussain, N., & Oad, S. (2023). The Rome Statute: A Critical Review Of The Role Of The Swgca In Defining The Crime Of Aggression. Pakistan Journal of International Affairs, 6(1).
Khan, A., Iqbal, N., & Ahmad, I. (2022). Human Trafficking in Pakistan: A Qualitative Analysis. Journal of Social Sciences Review, 2(3), 257-268.
Khan, A., Javed, K., Khan, A. S., & Rizwi, A. (2022). Aggression and individual criminal responsibility in the perspective of Islamic law.
Khan, A., Jillani, M. A. H. S., Abdelrehim Hammad, A. A., & Soomro, N. E. H. (2021). Plurilateral negotiation of WTO E-commerce in the context of digital economy: Recent issues and developments. Journal of Law and Political Sciences.
Khan, A., Usman, M., & Amjad, S. (2020). Enforcing Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights: A Global Imperative. International Review of Social Sciences (IRSS), 8(09).
KHAN, A., USMAN, M., & RIAZ, N. (2021). The Intersectionality of Human Rights: Addressing Multiple Discrimination. Asian Social Studies and Applied Research (ASSAR), 2(03), 498-502.
Malik, W., Gul, S., & Qureshi, G. M. (2025). Regulating Artificial Intelligence: Challenges for Data Protection and Privacy in Developing Nations. Journal of Social Signs Review, 3(05), 95-108.
Mujeeb, A. (2025). Pakistan's 18th Amendment: An Analysis Of Provincial Autonomy And Governance Reforms. Contemporary Journal of Social Science Review, 3(1), 147-151.
Obasun, O. (2024). Reimagining Nigerian Governance: A Case for Tribal Federalism. International Journal of Research and Innovation in Social Science, 8(11), 1161-1174.
Osaghae, E. E. (2020). Federal solutions to state failure in Africa. Nordiska Afrikainstitutet; Uppsala universitet.
Spytska, L. (2023). Historical-retrospective and legal analysis of the conditions, values and consequences of the Constitution of Pylyp Orlyk. Foreign Affairs, 33(1), 32-38.
Taylor, W. K. (2023). Judicial Agency and the Adjudication of Social Rights. Human Rights Quarterly, 45(2), 283-305.
Umar, D. J. D. U., & Jongur, D. (2024). Rethinking Of Fiscal Federalism: Challenges Of Revenue Allocation And Inter-Governmental Relations In Nigeria. ADSU International Journal of Applied Economics, Finance and Management, 9(1).
Usman, M. U. H. A. M. M. A. D., Khan, A. S. I. F., & Amjad, S. O. H. A. I. L. (2021). State Responsibility and International Law: Bridging the Gap.
Zhang, S., Li, Y., Xu, C., & Xiong, Z. (2024). Does fiscal decentralization reduce environmental degradation through mitigating resource mismatch and digital transformation? Evidence from China's resource-based cities. Resources Policy, 95, 105155.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Najeeb Ullah khan
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
